Monday, September 16, 2013

round up vs. great circle


the pendleton round-up is a special event, in so much as it is the anniversary of my living in eastern oregon.  i moved to eastern oregon a few days before the 100th round up.  i didn’t go that year, or the second year.  but i have been to round up the last two years and i have to say, it’s pretty overrated.  no, it’s extremely over rated.  the first time was fun, but with little context.  a few weeks before my first round up, i went to walla walla fair and frontier days.  these were the first rodeos i had been to since i was a kid, not that I went to a whole lot of rodeos when i was a kid, maybe two or three and those being so long ago, pendleton and walla walla were, for all practical purposes, the first ones.

over the past year, i have also been to the union stock show and elgin stampede. i considered going to chief joseph days, because it gets talked up like a mini round up. but an acquaintance who grew up in wallowa county told me that it was overrated and i shouldn’t waste my time going that far for only that reason.  after elgin and union, i didn’t feel much need to go to other rodeos.  one of the first things to know about me is that i am not into events for the social scene.  when i go to a sporting event, concert or whatever, i am attracted to the competition and entertainment and not the hanging out, chatting, seeing the sights and all that.  i care about excitement on the field.  i almost prefer to attend sporting events alone, or at least with someone who is interested in the specifics of the sport and won’t talk my ear off.  if the social scene is what you’re into, then maybe the pendleton round up is for you.

my first round up certainly paled in comparison to walla walla. that rodeo is held in conjunction with the county fair, so there is a much larger carnival, animal showing, and various other performances that accompany it.  it’s really not fair to hold fair and frontier days in comparison to another strictly rodeo event.  but then again, the round up is not strictly a rodeo either, and for that the rodeo itself suffers.

to compare pendleton to elgin or union is also not fair.  those rodeos clearly are superior.  the on-field activity is not for the faint of heart.  the animals in those more “minor” rodeos are far more fierce.  the spectator will actually see the cowboys carted off the field. at the elgin stampede, just with the bucking broncs, i saw a guy carried off with a broken leg and another break his wrist on a bucking horse before he could even get out of the chute. the horse was so ready to throw the guy off that it tried to jump out before the chute opened and got caught up, straddling the fence.  that extreme activity doesn’t happen in pendleton, though the p.a. announcer hypes how real it is while it is isn’t really happening.  pendleton is famously known for “let ‘er buck” only problem is that when one actually watches the horses, it is obvious they are barely kicking their back feet.  in union, the horses buck until they are nearly perpendicular to the ground.  in pendleton, the p.a. announcer praises that “this is a former world champion bucking horse!” even though by the time a horse becomes a champion, it has to be pretty old.  the former champion this year was twenty years old.  i wouldn’t go to a baseball game to see a former champion take his last swings and misses, i would want to see him smashing home runs in the prime of his career.  the horses in elgin and union are the horses in the prime of their careers.  i will give pendleton a little reprieve from the fact that it is late in the season and take panda’s excuse that maybe the horses are tired of being mean all summer.  fair enough, i suppose, but don’t brag the broncs up as the best. “let ‘er buck?”  what is bucking?   the p.a. announcer continually telling me that “these are the best in the world” is a joke because round up is not even the best rodeo in eastern oregon.

without much excitement on the field, the main point to notice is the exclusivity and pompous invite-only activities that makes the round up seem like the kentucky derby of northwest rodeos.  i got a more humble awakening to this other side to the round up that most people will never be a part of when my boss was invited by a group to sit in the exclusive box seats that need to be reserved years in advance that costs an entire paycheck for some us and comes with access to all the other rooms and buildings that one wonders what happens inside of.  but she has lived here for her entire life and has been to enough rodeos that driving an hour to go to one when there are several more closer is not that attractive, especially when she is told that she has to dress nice.  she says, “i have to dress up?  to go to a rodeo?  no thanks.  take someone else.”  people like that are my heroes and make me happy to have the job i do.  

and then to consider the lines, the clogged up traffic, the pay-to-park, the lack of access to even shake the hands of the athletes, and so on…there is an entirely ridiculous rigamarole to even buying a beer.  you have to find one guy on a mezzanine who checks i.d’s and puts on wristbands.  then, with the wrist band, you go to a window to purchase tokens for four dollars each.  then you go stand in a longer line to exchange a token for your choice of either a coors light draft or a can of a hard lemonade.  can i go back to elgin where i just stand in one line of three or four people and show my i.d. to the person pouring the beer?  not to mention there is a killer brewery in pendleton.  why can i not buy prodigal son beer at round up?  needless to say, i wouldn’t have a beer at round up.  instead i went to the great satan of soda to try and keep myself awake through the boredom of it all.  but then i am told that the only options are coca-cola and sprite.  i ask for a sprite and the guy reaches down to pick up a watered-down soda from a stockpile that was poured five minutes earlier to be fast enough meet the high demands of the crowds.  the guy never even smiled, and none of the experience was worth my putting a tip into his bucket.

following round up, they have an “evening entertainment program” in happy canyon that depicts the history of horrors of indians in the region.  the night show was toned down more this year than last.  this year, the window in the chinese laundry mat was shot out. last year, they burned the thing down and relentlessly tormented the chinese people who were actually just more white people wearing straw hats.  and every old west store front has perfectly crafted signs in beautifully written fonts, except for the chinese laundry mat, which is written in chinese characters with handwriting worse than a kindergartener would do. overall, the racism and indian genocide shown in the performance can be passed off theatre, a portrayal of the way times were.  meanwhile, the crowd cheering as the white man rises to the top forcing the removal of indians can be considered a portrayal of the way times still are.

as much a waste of time as round up was, i wouldn’t have minded to go back to pendleton the next night when work wasn’t part of the picture and i could do the in-town concerts, carnival and and other stuff that was twelve blocks away on main street and virtually impossible to get to for people tied up at the rodeo grounds and happy canyon night show.  jd kindle and the playboys were on at the GP two nights in a row.  it would have been a good time, but!!  in la grande we now have an event during round up weekend to give people in union county an alternative to going to pendleton.

this was the second year of the great circle.  it’s a benefit concert for the blue mountains conservancy organized by colt haney and some other down to earth to people that make it much more inviting than a rodeo in a huge stadium.  the great circle is a new enough thing that there is no exclusive access.  the artists and maybe some volunteers have v.i.p. passes, but otherwise the most exclusive access is a $25 wristband to take part in all three days of activities, camping and all that.  that’s only $7 more than to sit in the top row for a single four-hour rodeo.  this is to say that my preferred concert experience is about the same as my preferred sporting event.  to me, these are about seeing the performance and not going home afterwards to try to see myself on tv while watching a replay. great circle is a event big enough that you know a lot of the songs by heart, but small enough that anyone can walk backstage or drink with the bands in the beer garden.  and while the recycling doesn’t reach my rigorous standards, i can at least leave a cup with my name on it next to the kegs that i reuse every time i go back for another beer.  and, yes, it’s real beer brewed here in oregon by 2 kilts. and while the food may not have been as locally sourced as i would prefer, it’s not just processed junk food either.  the menu puts to shame any and all eating establishments in la grande.

great circle was perfect. the bands are top notch and the experience was a “one of a lifetime” type event, except that it happens annually.  even the electricity surges a few times didn’t interrupt the music, it only made the bands and the dancing crowd more engaged and together.  never again should anyone expect to find me at round up, i would choose great circle any day over round up.  with land blessings and conservation efforts to preserve the wilderness surrounding the great circle, the money spent to attend the event goes to a much greater cause than the commercialization of a rodeo in a town that competes to be the biggest “city” in eastern oregon.  even the genocide of the indians took on a more positive light at great circle with ghost wind singing songs of how the indians are rising up and reclaiming their lands, buying some of it back (as if they should have to pay for it, but i am just pessimistic in that way).  it’s an encouraging spirit, not one of “oh that sucked, but oh well this is the way it is now” mentality that permeates most of the rest of an apathetic society.

as i think back on it all, the year that has been…seeing the EOU ladies play at nationals in iowa, to keol fest, to the rodeo season, to all the events at liberty theatre, to my little tiff with the observer last week, one thing clearly comes into focus.  i volunteer my time to a radio station, that like most other free-form, non-commercial entities, struggles to survive. news, music, sports and entertainment are cutthroat businesses.  that holds no attraction to me.  i am not in this to cut throats.  i would rather cut my own throat than someone elses, even that of my most ardent enemy.  that is why it’s tough to watch the happy canyon night show.  i feel more for the indians than the white men, then and now.  i put myself in the same position, vulnerable though it may be to not play along with the expansionist agendas.  the day i start doing this to get ahead, or to be cool, is the day i exit the game.  i operate now, as always, to help provide people with an alternative to the lame over rated activities that divide people into exclusive groups: those with tickets vs. those without, those with v.i.p. passes and so forth.  once an event gets too much of an important of a level, it becomes a ho-hum event that continues for the sake of a reputation and a profit rather than it’s original purpose and that is why new alternatives are needed.  in short, i live to bring fun to a town that is virtually impossible to have fun in.  that by itself is already a hard enough job, i don’t want a harder more convoluted job than that.  

this is all maddening because (as i sound like a broken record) not only is there on the one side of the fence people trying to make it hard to allow fun things to happen, but there is the other side of the fence of people that seem to not even care enough to want to attend the events.  for as successful as events like great circle, keol fest and others have been, more people will leave la grande to go see the pendleton round up than come out to the great circle.  that’s pathetic.  still, we continue in hope that it will change, that someday people will appreciate what is in their own back yard more than what is in another town.  i am still looking back to march when holiday friends, a nationally touring band, stopped in at ten depot.  two days later, they played a outdoor stage to thousands of people in boise.  though they can practically have groupies clamoring for backstage access in another city, they had five people show up to see them here.  that will never make sense to me, but it does help me understand why people still remember the eagles coming to la grande in 1976, and people still remember that it was 1976 specifically, not that it was in the 1970s in general.  people remember it so specifically because it will never happen again.  the social community is like a plant.  if you give it water, it will grow bigger and bigger.  if not, it withers and dies.  if there is no support for the musicians that are willing to play here now, then there will be no incentive for bigger musicians to play here in the future.  we will continue to have people talking about seeing taylor swift’s tour busses passing by on I-84 on the way to portland, as if that is a big deal.  that’s the extent of the excitement.  and the fans of people like that will continue going to portland for entertainment and not care or even know that better things happen right here. 

between a city that doesn’t want anything fun to happen and an audience that remains apathetic to whether something fun will ever happen, that’s the ho-hum life la grande will continue to support.  the same way that deeply disturbing salon article about jadin bell showed a parallel that la grande is exactly the same town now that it was 48 years ago, la grande will still be the same town in 48 years from now no doubt.  i predict that island city will surpass la grande in population within 48 years.  yet despite all it’s problems in some ways, it makes la grande the perfect place for me.  it makes an environment where i can help paint the picture.  when things are so dead, it makes everything we do get to do that much better.  it’s almost contradictory and only really makes sense on a deeper level.  this is still somewhere that a fun event can entice people away from pendleton on round up weekend, even if they are the minority.  it’s better to follow the minority than the majority.  for now, it makes me happy to be here and surely, like everyone else, it’ll be what someday makes me leave for somewhere else, but it’ll add an interesting and very different chapter to my life story no doubt.  there can be alternatives, even in la grande.  they just cost a little more, in terms of effort, but then i guess we get what we pay for. 

No comments:

Post a Comment